How woodcocks evolved to be the weird cousins of their family
Left: An American woodcock. Photo © Cameron Rutt. Right: John Bates with sandpipers, including woodcocks and snipes, in the Field Museum's collections. Photo © Field Museum.
A woodcock is an odd little bird with a long, skinny bill and a plump, chunky body that's shaped like an American football. It mostly hangs out near the ground, but it does a mating display in which it makes a buzzy, tweeting call and then takes off zigzagging across the sky. The woodcock stands out from most of the members of its family, the sandpipers. The majority of sandpiper species are champion migrators who traverse thousands of miles every year, but many woodcock species and their closest cousins, the snipes, have evolved to migrate shorter distances. Some island-dwelling species of woodcocks and snipes don't migrate at all. A new research project, published in the journal the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, delved into the birds' DNA to figure out how the 8 living species of woodcocks and 22 species of snipes got to be the sometimes non-migratory "weird cousins" of the sandpiper family.
"The distribution of woodcocks and snipes around the world is really unusual," says John Bates, a co-author of the study and curator of birds at the Field Museum's Negaunee Integrative Research Center. "There are eight living species of woodcocks, and six of them are found only on islands. We wanted to know how they got there and at what point they split off from the rest of the sandpiper family. They're not terribly aerodynamic, and yet they've clearly gotten around."
Bates began working on the project several years ago when one of the paper's co-authors, João Capurucho, did a post-doctoral fellowship at the Field Museum. "João was interested in the history of migration, so we decided that shorebirds would be an interesting group to look into, since so many of them have such long migratory paths," says Bates.
From there, Capurucho and Bates collaborated with a team of scientists at the Florida Museum of Natural History, who were studying the fossilized remains of a sandpiper found in a cave in Haiti, on the Caribbean island of Hispaniola. While there are no modern woodcocks in Hispaniola, this fossilized specimen lived there about a thousand years ago. The Florida team was curious about how this ancient bird was related to modern species.
The teams worked together to build the family tree of woodcocks and snipes, using the birds' DNA. "We used a lot of specimens from the Field Museum's collections for this study," says Bates. "There are 28 known species of woodcocks and snipes, and we have most of them here at the Field." By taking small samples of tissue from the birds' skin, the scientists were able to sequence the birds' genetic codes, and build a family tree documenting how the DNA connected one species to the next.
"Snipes and woodcocks have been around for 20 to 25 million years," says Bates. "Over that time, as new species have evolved and moved around the world, their migratory patterns have changed too." Like other sandpipers,' early ancestors lived in the northern hemisphere, and as they migrated, they established new populations on various islands at lower latitudes, which eventually evolved into new species. Many of these new species, which lived closer to the equator than their forebears, wound up migrating less or not at all, but that did not mean they always stayed in these new places. The authors suggest that snipe in Africa crossed the Atlantic Ocean to create a lineage of species in South America and crossed the Pacific Ocean to found a group of species in and around New Zealand. The researchers' data also allowed the group to determine that the Hispaniolan fossil is a snipe and not a woodcock, as initially thought.
The study helps round out scientists' understanding of how this group of shorebirds have evolved and moved over time, but it's especially relevant given the ways that climate change and habitat destruction are changing when and where birds are able to live and breed.
"These are definitely birds that would be affected by changing habitats and changing climates. Some of these woodcocks are found only in the mountain forests on islands between Asia and Australia, and if those forests get cut down, the birds are going to be gone too," says Bates. "And snipes live in grasslands, which are habitats that people ignore or turn into pastures and farmland. Finding out more about how these birds have evolved their movements is important for conservation work in the future."
This study was authored by Min Zhao (Virginia Tech and Florida Natural History Museum), João Marcos Guimarães Capurucho (Field Museum and Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora), Brian Stucky (Florida Museum of Natural History and U.S. Department of Agriculture), David W. Steadman (Florida Museum of Natural History), John Bates (Field Museum), Michelle J. LeFebvre (Florida Museum of Natural History), Robert P. Guralnick (Florida Museum of Natural History), Julie M. Allen (Virginia Tech), and Jessica A. Oswald (Florida Museum of Natural History, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service).